Current:Home > NewsJudge orders retrial of civil case against contractor accused of abuse at Abu Ghraib -TrueNorth Finance Path
Judge orders retrial of civil case against contractor accused of abuse at Abu Ghraib
View
Date:2025-04-15 03:03:27
ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — A judge on Friday ordered a retrial over allegations that a Virginia-based military contractor contributed to the abuse and torture of detainees at Iraq’s notorious Abu Ghraib prison two decades ago.
A civil trial earlier this year ended with a hung jury and mistrial, with the eight-person panel split on whether contractor CACI bore responsibility for abuse of the three Abu Ghraib survivors who filed suit. Two jurors told The Associated Press after the mistrial that a majority of the jury wanted to hold CACI liable. A unanimous jury verdict is required in federal civil cases.
CACI supplied civilian interrogators to the prison in 2003 and 2004 to supplement a lack of military interrogators. The lawsuit alleged that those interrogators conspired with soldiers there to abuse detainees as a means of “softening them up” for questioning.
At a hearing Friday, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema said she’d “gone back and forth” over whether a new trial is merited, but ultimately decided the plaintiffs were within their rights to retry the case.
After she declared the mistrial last month, Brinkema had questioned from the bench whether a new trial would be a good idea.
It took a massive effort and 16 years of legal wrangling to bring case to trial in the first place. The trial was the first time a U.S. jury heard claims brought by Abu Ghraib survivors in the 20 years since photos of detainee mistreatment — accompanied by smiling U.S. soldiers inflicting the abuse — shocked the world during the U.S. occupation of Iraq.
The trial itself lasted only a week but the jury deliberated for eight days .
In court papers opposing a retrial, CACI argued that “Plaintiffs received their day in court, a day in court that shined a light on the Abu Ghraib scandal as brightly as the state secrets privilege will allow. The evidence presented at trial demonstrates beyond doubt that a jury ... could not reasonably return any verdict other than a verdict in CACI’s favor.”
CACI said it was hampered in defending itself because the government asserted that large swaths of evidence were classified and could not be presented in a public trial. The judge on Friday said the government’s use of the state secrets privilege caused difficulties for the plaintiffs as well.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs, who were represented by the Center for Constitutional Rights, had argued that they were entitled to a retrial by right, and that the judge could only preclude it if CACI could show that no reasonable jury would hold it liable.
During the trial, the jury asked questions that demonstrated they were divided and unsure how to apply a legal principle called the “borrowed servants” doctrine. CACI, as one of its defenses, argued it shouldn’t be liable for any misdeeds by its employees if they were under the control and direction of the Army.
The plaintiffs’ lawyers tried to bar CACI from making that argument at trial, but Brinkema allowed the jury to consider it.
Both sides argued about the scope of the doctrine. Fundamentally, though, if CACI could prove its interrogators were under the command and control of the Army at the time any misconduct occurred, then the jury was instructed to find in favor of CACI.
While it took 16 years to bring the first case to trial, it should not take nearly as long to conduct a retrial. Brinkema said she wants the retrial to be held this year, and both sides indicated that they were initially amenable to an October trial date.
Many of the witnesses at the trial testified by recorded deposition, including several of the soldiers who guarded the prison and were convicted in courts-martial of abusing detainees. As a result, it’s likely that their testimony could just be replayed to a new jury.
veryGood! (4473)
Related
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Biden orders strikes on an Iranian-aligned group after 3 US troops wounded in drone attack in Iraq
- The Indicators of this year and next
- Offshore wind in the U.S. hit headwinds in 2023. Here's what you need to know
- Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
- Spend Your Gift Cards on These Kate Spade Bags That Start at $48
- Nick Cannon's Christmas Gift From Bre Tiesi Is a Nod to All 12 of His Kids
- What is Boxing Day? Learn more about the centuries-old tradition
- Pressure on a veteran and senator shows what’s next for those who oppose Trump
- Man trapped for 6 days in wrecked truck in Indiana rescued after being spotted by passersby
Ranking
- Romantasy reigns on spicy BookTok: Recommendations from the internet’s favorite genre
- Beer battered fillets stocked at Whole Foods recalled nationwide over soy allergen
- Tax season can be terrifying. Here's everything to know before filing your taxes in 2024.
- Here’s what to know about Turkey’s decision to move forward with Sweden’s bid to join NATO
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Map shows where blue land crabs are moving, beyond native habitat in Florida, Texas
- Hyundai recalls 2023: Check the full list of models recalled this year
- A US delegation to meet with Mexican government for talks on the surge of migrants at border
Recommendation
How to watch the 'Blue Bloods' Season 14 finale: Final episode premiere date, cast
The death toll in a Romania guesthouse blaze rises to 7. The search for missing persons is ongoing
Burning Man survived a muddy quagmire. Will the experiment last 30 more years?
National Weather Service warns of high surf for some of Hawaii’s shores
Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
Hey, that gift was mine! Toddler opens entire family's Christmas gifts at 3 am
Anthropologie's End-of Season Sale is Here: Save an Extra 40% off on Must-Have Fashion, Home & More
US ambassador thanks Japan for defense upgrade and allowing a Patriot missile sale to US